Should You Fire Your Financial Advisor?
See if leaving pays for itself

Four quick taps show what it would cost you to leave, what you'd save, and how long leaving takes to pay for itself. Sometimes the honest answer is to stay. Don't know your fee? No worries: we'll start you with a common one. Free, no sign-up.

Math you can check yourselfSources: SEC, FINRA, IRSEducation, not advice
Question 1 of 4
Each answer builds your free app

Educational illustration only. A rule of thumb from your answers, not advice and not a promise of any result.

Adviser Report Card

Is the money the only problem? Grade what you get

Cost is one reason to leave. Service is the other. Ten yes-or-no questions on what a good adviser does give you a grade from A to F and a list of what to ask about before you decide. About one minute, no sign-up.

A checklist, not a rating of anyone's skill or results. We're an adviser too, so weigh it with that in mind.

Should you fire your financial advisor? The short answer

Leave when you're paying for work that isn't getting done, or when you can't get a straight answer about what you pay. Leaving because of one bad year usually isn't enough, since every portfolio has those. Before you go, work out what leaving costs. Some accounts cost nothing to move. Others carry charges or taxes that can take years to earn back.

You can usually leave at any time. Your agreement sets the notice it wants and any fees, so read it first.

Good reasons to leave

  • You can't get your total cost in dollars. The SEC tells investors to ask how much an investment has to rise before they break even after fees. If your adviser can't tell you what you pay, that's the place to start.
  • You don't have a plan, only a portfolio. Nobody has looked at your pension, taxes, beneficiaries or when you'll draw the money.
  • They only call when they have something to sell. Check whether they're a fiduciary all the time, or only on some accounts.
  • They went quiet in a bad market. That's when good help is worth the most.
  • Their record has problems. Look up any person or firm on the SEC's free background check.

When staying may make more sense

  • You're inside a surrender period and the charge is larger than what you'd save for years.
  • You'd have to sell at a big taxable gain in a regular account.
  • You're upset about one bad year, but the plan, the service and the cost are all fine.
  • The fee wouldn't drop. If you'd pay the same elsewhere, the case for moving has to be better service. Our fee calculator shows what your current fee costs over time.

What it can cost to leave

How to fire your financial advisor, step by step

  1. Read your agreement. Look for how much notice it asks for and any fee for leaving.
  2. List what you own. Ask which holdings can't move, and when any charge ends.
  3. Decide where the money is going first. The SEC says transfers start and end with your new firm, so you don't need your old adviser's permission to begin.
  4. Fill out the transfer form. FINRA calls it a Transfer Initiation Form. Attach your latest statement and keep a copy.
  5. Send written notice. Keep it short, and ask for a refund of any fee you paid in advance. SEC examiners found some advisers refunded prepaid fees only if the client asked (2021), including clients who left through the custodian. So ask.
  6. Hold off on trading. FINRA says buying and selling during a transfer often delays it.
  7. Check that it all landed. Compare holdings against your last statement, and make sure your cost records came across.

How long it takes. FINRA says the two main steps generally take about three to four business days, and longer for IRAs and accounts coming from a bank or fund company. The SEC's guide says to count on two to three weeks for the whole process.

What to say. "Please accept this as written notice that I'm ending our advisory agreement as of [date]. Please stop billing my accounts as of that date and refund any fee I paid in advance for time after it. Please send me my agreement, my latest statements and my cost basis records. My new firm will start the transfer. Thank you for your work." That's enough. You don't owe anyone a long explanation. The free app has this letter ready to copy.

If you have a 457, 401(k), TSP or pension

A workplace plan isn't an account your adviser can simply hand over. Whether the money can move depends on the plan and on whether you've left the job, so ask the plan first. If it can move, have it sent directly to the new account. A check made out to you usually has 20% held back for federal tax, or $20,000 on every $100,000. Sometimes leaving the money in the plan is the better choice. Your pension stays with your pension fund whoever your adviser is.

If you move to us

We handle the transfer paperwork with you: opening the new accounts, sending the forms and following the move until it lands. We'd check what can move, and what it would cost, before anything happens. We earn our fee only on money you move to us, so weigh what we say with that in mind. Leaving us works the same way as leaving anyone else. Our agreement runs until either side ends it in writing, and the last fee is pro-rated to the days we served you (Form ADV, Item 5).

What Eslyn's video covers

If you ask for one in the app, Eslyn Hernandez, your point of contact here, looks at your numbers and sends you a short video on what they show and what to ask your current adviser. It is general education, not a recommendation to stay, leave, buy or sell. Investing questions go to Will Harrison, our Chief Investment Officer, on a call.

What you get for our fee

One fee covers two jobs: planning your whole financial life, and managing your investments. There is no extra charge for either.

1. Your financial plan, built with you and checked every year

We start by understanding your situation, then we follow the same seven steps that CFP Board sets for financial planning:

  1. Understand your situation. Your pension, 457, savings, debts, insurance, family and benefits.
  2. Set your goals with you. When you want to stop working, the income you need, and what you want to leave behind.
  3. See where your current path leads, and what the other paths look like.
  4. Build our recommendations.
  5. Walk you through them in plain words, so you know why, not just what.
  6. Help you put them in place: opening accounts, moving money, updating beneficiaries.
  7. Meet once a year, included in the fee, to check progress and update the plan when your life or the rules change.

Where the plan starts: your numbers. We build your budget and cash flow (what comes in and goes out each month) and your balance sheet (what you own and what you owe). Those two pages drive every other decision in the plan.

How we test it. We plan around your goals, such as retiring at a certain age or paying for a child's college. Then we run scenarios, like retiring a year later or taking a different pension option, and a Monte Carlo test. That test runs your plan through thousands of possible market paths to show how often the money lasts.

Example: "We want to buy a home." This is how a goal moves through those seven steps. First we look at where you stand today: your income statement (what comes in and goes out each month) and your balance sheet (what you own and owe). Then we test whether the down payment, closing costs and the new monthly cost fit with what you have now, without starving your retirement savings. If they fit, we map out when and how. If they don't yet, we lay out the choices: costs to cut, a later date, a smaller price, or another way to fund the down payment, and show what each one does to the rest of your plan. You pick the path, we help put it in place, and we check it at every yearly meeting.

What the plan covers:

  • Retirement income. When to draw from your pension, 457, IRAs and savings, in what order, and when to claim Social Security.
  • Tax planning. Keeping more of what you earn: which account to draw from first, staying in lower tax brackets, and Roth conversions in low-income years.
  • Roth IRAs. You pay tax on the money going in, and qualified withdrawals come out tax-free. You are never forced to take money out during your lifetime. For 2026 you can put in up to $7,500, or $8,600 at age 50 and up, if your income is under the IRS limits.
  • Opening the right accounts. Traditional and Roth IRAs, individual and joint accounts, set up and titled to match the plan.
  • 401(k), 403(b) and 457 rollovers. If moving the money makes sense, we have it sent straight to the new account. That avoids the 20% tax withholding that comes with a check made out to you. Sometimes leaving the money in your plan is the better choice, and we will tell you when it is.
  • Insurance planning. Making sure your life, disability, long-term care and home coverage fit the risks you actually have. We do not sell insurance and take no commissions.
  • Estate planning. Your beneficiaries, account titles, will and powers of attorney, checked so they all say the same thing as your plan.

2. Your investments, managed all year by Will Harrison

Will Harrison, our Chief Investment Officer, runs the portfolios, and most of the work is research you never see. He studies and follows the companies we own and the ones we might own: their results, their managers, and the trends around them. He decides what to buy, when to add, and when to sell, and he writes up his thinking every quarter in Inside the Portfolio. His approach:

  • He owns good businesses. Companies with steady cash flow, strong returns, an edge competitors struggle to copy, and managers who own a real stake.
  • He thinks in years, not quarters. He looks out three to five years, not at the latest headline.
  • He buys when others are scared. When a price falls but the business is still doing well, he adds to it.
  • He keeps risk in check. New ideas start small, winners get trimmed when better ideas come along, and he will not chase the biggest names just because they dominate the index.

Day to day, the portfolio work also includes:

  • Rebalancing. When markets push your mix off target, we bring it back. That means trimming what went up and buying what went down, which is hard to make yourself do.
  • Tax-loss harvesting. When an investment in a regular taxable account is down, we can sell it to lock in the loss and buy something similar so you stay invested. The loss can cancel out taxable gains, and up to $3,000 a year of other income, with the rest carried to later years. It does not apply inside IRAs or 457s, where there is no tax on gains to save.
  • Watching for wash sales. The IRS throws out the loss if the same or a nearly identical investment is bought within 30 days before or after the sale, and that includes buys in your IRA or Roth IRA. We plan the replacement purchase around that window so the loss counts.
  • Putting each holding in the right account. Investments that pay a lot of taxable income go in IRAs, where they grow tax-deferred. Ones that are taxed lightly go in taxable accounts.

What research says advice is worth

Vanguard's research estimates that advisers who follow practices like these can add about 3 percentage points a year to net returns. The biggest piece, about 1.5 points, comes from coaching people to stay invested when markets drop. Vanguard is clear that this is not a steady yearly number. It shows up unevenly, mostly when markets panic or soar, and it varies a lot from person to person. These are Vanguard's estimates across many investors, not a promise of what we will add for you. Sources: Vanguard Advisor's Alpha and its research paper (February 2019).

How we are paid

We charge a percentage of what we manage, and we take no commissions. From our Form ADV brochure, Items 5 and 6:

  • 1% a year for first responders, active military, reserve and veterans.
  • 2% a year for other clients with accounts under $1.1 million.
  • Over $1.1 million: 0.5% a year plus 25% of profits above a 4% return.

The fee is taken from your account each month for the month before. Trading costs and the funds' own expenses are separate. How your adviser gets paid, in full.

Want to see costs over the years? Try the fee calculator. Not sure you need an adviser at all? Take the worth-it test. Have money with an adviser now? Get a free portfolio review.

Who we are

Sirmium Capital LLC is a small, independent investment firm in New York, registered as an investment adviser with the State of New York. You can look us up on the SEC's public adviser database under CRD #167682, where our full brochure is posted.

Common questions

Usually, yes. Your agreement says how much notice it wants and whether there's a fee for leaving. Charges on what you own, such as an annuity surrender charge, are separate from the adviser's agreement and can still apply.
Your new firm starts the transfer, so the move can begin without your adviser's sign-off. Tell them anyway, in writing, and ask for any prepaid fee back. SEC examiners found some advisers refunded prepaid fees only if the client asked.
Not for moving the same holdings to a new firm, because that isn't a sale. You can owe tax if something is sold in a regular taxable account at a gain. Selling inside an IRA, 401(k) or 457 isn't taxed.
FINRA says the main steps generally take about three to four business days, and longer for IRAs and accounts held at a bank or fund company. The SEC's guide says to count on two to three weeks in all.
An annuity usually can't move like a regular account, and leaving early can bring a surrender charge. Ask for the charge in dollars and the date it ends. Put that figure in the calculator as your cost to get out.
Keep it short and in writing: the date you're ending the agreement, a request to stop billing, a refund of anything prepaid, and copies of your records. There's a sample above, and the app has it ready to copy.
No. It looks at cost alone, and it tells some people that staying costs less for now. If that's you, we'd rather you know. It's an illustration from your answers, not advice.
They reach us as you type them, even before you give us a name or email, so we can see which questions people bring. Our privacy policy has the details. The calculator, the app, the video and a 15-minute call are free.

Educational information only. Not investment, tax or legal advice, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and not a guarantee. We earn our fee only on money you move to us, so weigh what we say with that in mind. Sirmium Capital LLC is a New York state-registered investment adviser and is not registered with the SEC. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.