Home/457(b)

The 457(b) Rule That
a Rollover Can Cost You

A governmental 457(b) is the only major retirement account you can tap at any age after you leave service without a 10% penalty. Roll it into an IRA and that advantage can disappear. See what it is worth in your own numbers.

Run the numbers: free, 2 minutes

Quick answer

Distributions from a governmental 457(b) are not subject to the 10% early withdrawal tax, at any age, once you separate from service. The IRS puts it plainly: an eligible state or local government 457 plan "isn't a qualified retirement plan and any distribution from such plan isn't subject to the 10% additional tax on early distributions." Roll that money into a traditional IRA and it becomes IRA money, which is subject to the 10% additional tax before age 59½. If you retire in your forties or fifties and expect to spend from this account before 59½, the timing of a rollover matters more than almost anything else you will decide about it.

Free calculator

What a rollover would cost you

Nothing is saved and nothing is sent. The numbers stay in your browser.

Your situation

If you do not expect to touch it before 59½, enter 0. The penalty question only bites on money you actually take out early.
Affects the 401(k) and 401(a) side only, not the 457.

What it costs

Penalty if you roll to an IRA first $0 Enter your numbers to see the comparison.
Years from separation to 59½0
Withdrawn before 59½$0
Left in the 457: penalty$0
Rolled to an IRA: penalty$0
401(k) or 401(a) penalty$0

Your 2026 limits

Used only to check the Roth catch-up rule. Wages are counted per employer, not household income.
NYC's Deferred Compensation Plan offers both, and the limits are separate.

What you can defer

Your 2026 maximum $0
457 Plan limit$0
401(k) Plan limit$0
Catch-up you qualify forNone
Catch-up must be Roth?No

Estimates for education only, not tax or investment advice, and not a recommendation to take or delay a distribution. Figures reflect 2026 IRS limits and the New York City Deferred Compensation Plan's published rules. Your own plan's terms control, state tax is not modelled, and ordinary income tax still applies to pre-tax withdrawals whether or not a penalty does. Confirm your situation with your plan and a tax professional.
The table NYC publishes

When the 10% penalty applies

The New York City Deferred Compensation Plan publishes this grid for its own participants. Read the first row against the last one. The 457 never triggers the penalty. A traditional IRA triggers it at every age until 59½. That difference is the entire reason rollover timing matters.

PlanUnder 50Age 50 to 54Age 55 to 59½59½ and older
457NoNoNoNo
401(k)YesNo*NoNo
401(a)YesNoNoNo
Traditional NYCE IRAYesYesYesNo

* Effective for distributions after December 31, 2015. Source: New York City Deferred Compensation Plan, "When does the 10% Penalty Apply." The 401(k) and 401(a) exemption at age 50 comes from the Pension Protection Act of 2006 and the Defending Public Safety Employees' Retirement Act of 2015, and covers police protection, firefighting services and emergency medical services. It is claimed on IRS Form 5329.

Where we will argue against ourselves

A rollover is how firms like ours get paid

It is worth being direct about that. When you move a 457 to an IRA, an advisory firm can manage it and charge a fee on it. When you leave it at the Deferred Compensation Plan, we cannot.

And a rollover can still be the right call. DCP has a limited fund menu, no ability to hold individual positions, and rules that may not fit an estate plan. Those are real reasons people move money, and they do not disappear because of the penalty rule.

But if you separate at 47 and expect to live on this money at 52, a rollover done at the wrong time can cost you ten cents on every dollar you touch before 59½. That is not a detail to discover afterwards. The honest answer for a lot of members is to leave some of it in the 457 as the bridge to 59½ and move the rest, and the only way to know the split is to look at your actual spending plan.

Talk it through: free 15 minutes

No products, no commissions. Planning conversations are led by our Chief Investment Officer, William Harrison, the firm's registered adviser.

Common questions

457(b) questions we get most

For a governmental 457(b), yes. The IRS states that an eligible state or local government section 457 deferred compensation plan is not a qualified retirement plan, and any distribution from such a plan is not subject to the 10% additional tax on early distributions. The New York City Deferred Compensation Plan confirms it for its own participants: upon severance from City employment, or upon reaching age 59½, 457 Plan participants can receive direct payments without penalty regardless of age. One exception applies. Any distribution attributable to money the 457 received in a transfer or rollover from a 401(k), 403(b), 403(a) plan or an IRA does remain subject to the 10% additional tax. Ordinary income tax still applies either way.
The exemption does not travel with the money. The NYC Deferred Compensation Plan states that 457 funds can be rolled over into other eligible retirement plans including a retail IRA, but once rolled over, funds may become subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty. IRS Topic 558 lists IRAs among the plans whose early distributions are subject to the 10% additional tax. For someone who separates in their forties or fifties and expects to draw on the money before 59½, a rollover can convert penalty-free access into penalty-exposed access. Whether it still makes sense depends on the rest of your plan, which is a conversation worth having before anything moves.
The 457(b) elective deferral limit is $24,500 for 2026, up from $23,500 in 2025. Participants in governmental 457(b) plans who are 50 or older may be eligible for a catch-up of up to $8,000, raising the limit to $32,500. Under SECURE 2.0, participants aged 60 through 63 can make a larger catch-up of up to $11,250 instead of $8,000 if the plan permits, which the New York City Deferred Compensation Plan lists as a $35,750 limit for 2026.
Yes. The IRS states that you have a separate deferral limit if you are also eligible to participate in a 457(b) plan, and that this limit is not combined with deferrals made to a 403(b) or other plans. New York City's Deferred Compensation Plan is made up of both a 457 Plan and a 401(k) Plan, and states plainly that employees can defer the maximum in both. For 2026 that is $24,500 to each before catch-up. A participant aged 60 to 63 eligible for the larger catch-up in both could reach $71,500 in one year. Eligibility depends on your employer and your plan, so confirm it rather than assume it.
DAR is the New York City Deferred Compensation Plan's name for the special three-year catch-up under Internal Revenue Code section 457(b)(3). In the three calendar years before the plan's Normal Retirement Age, the annual limit can be doubled. The catch that most explanations leave out is that it is only available to participants who have underutilized their 457 deferrals in prior years. The statute sets the ceiling at the lesser of twice the annual dollar amount or the current year ceiling plus unused amounts from earlier years, so a participant who has always contributed the maximum has no unused room and gains nothing from it. DAR also cannot be used in the same year as the age 50 or ages 60 to 63 catch-up.
Yes, and it is separate from the 457 rule. The NYC Deferred Compensation Plan states that under the Pension Protection Act of 2006 and the Defending Public Safety Employees' Retirement Act of 2015, effective January 1 2016, public safety workers age 50 or older who retire or separate from City service are exempt from the 10% early withdrawal tax on distributions from the 401(k) and 401(a) plans. Public safety employees include those providing police protection, firefighting services and emergency medical services. The exemption is claimed by filing IRS Form 5329 with your federal return. The 457 exemption is broader, because it applies at any age rather than requiring you to reach 50.
A 457(b) is a deferred compensation plan that lets employees save for retirement through payroll deductions. The IRS requires the sponsor to be a state or local government or a tax-exempt organization under section 501(c). Governmental plans hold assets in trust for the employee. Non-governmental 457(b) plans work differently: the IRS states that plan assets are not held in trust but remain the property of the employer and are available to its general creditors in the event of litigation or bankruptcy, the age 50 catch-up is not allowed, loans are not permitted, and participation must be limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees. New York City employees, including FDNY, NYPD and EMS, are in a governmental plan.
Go deeper

If you are planning a City retirement

FDNY pension calculatorTier 2 and Tier 3, VSF, and the 457 together. NYPD pension calculatorWhat 20 versus 25 years actually pays. Nurses and EMTsWhere a 403(b) and a 457 stack together. Tier 6 pension calculatorWhat retiring before 63 permanently costs. How we workFee-only, fiduciary, no commissions.